Change has been the only constant for the top job at the Lafayette Police Department since 2020. Six different people have held the job since 2020, including five appointed or promoted by former Mayor-President Josh Guillory.
Mayor-President Monique Boulet retained Guillory’s last permanent chief, Judith Estorge, when she took office in early 2024. Estorge announced her resignation in May, sending Lafayette Consolidated Government back to the drawing board and another national search.
| Name | Type | Term | Tenure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Toby Aguillard | Permanent | Nov. 3, 2016 – Jan. 6, 2020 | 3 years (1 day under Guillory) |
| Scott Morgan | Interim | Jan. 7, 2020 – Dec. 31, 2020 | 12 months |
| Thomas Glover | Permanent | Jan. 1, 2021 – Oct. 7, 2021 | 10 months |
| Wayne Griffin | Interim | Oct. 8, 2021 – Oct. 21, 2021 | 2 weeks |
| Monte Potier | Acting | Oct. 22, 2021 – present | 3 months |
| Judith Estorge | Permanent | Nov. 1, 2022 – May 28, 2024 | 19 months |
| Paul Trouard | Interim | May 28, 2024 | Current interim chief |
The Details
Estorge’s resignation comes as the Lafayette Police Department continues to struggle with vacancies, persistent violent crime and thinning ranks of leadership. Here’s a timeline of news links that document how we got here; it will be adjusted and updated as new information becomes available.
Dec. 13, 2019
Chief Toby Aguillard blindsided by Josh Guillory’s threat to fire him The Acadiana Advocate
“He made it very clear this is simply about politics,” Aguillard said of Guillory, who has never held elected office. “I believe that’s why civil service exists. I intend to fight it.”
Jan. 6, 2020
Aguillard resigns the day Guillory takes office; Lt. Scott Morgan appointed as interim chief, The Advertiser
“I did ask him to resign. He agreed to resign. He resigned in the afternoon today,” Guillory said. “That’s all I’m going to say on that for this right now.”
Jan. 9, 2020
Mayor-president: Sheriff, police conflict factored into asking Chief Aguillard to resign, The Advertiser
“Part of my decision making process was a significant hit to the relationship between the police department and the sheriff’s department,” Guillory said during the first of his new weekly call-in radio shows on KPEL radio. “And it’s not the actual boots on ground, it’s not the patrol officers out there. That was a leadership issue. I have no problem with saying that.”
Feb. 12, 2020
Guillory will launch nationwide search for new police chief; eliminates deputy chief position, The Current
Mayor-President Josh Guillory says he will start a nationwide search for a new police chief in the next 30 days and confirmed for the first time plans to eliminate Deputy Chief Reggie Thomas’s position.
July 8, 2020
Nationwide chief search attracts four local applicants, The Current
“If they’re all internal then I don’t know how successful we were on the national search,” Guillory said. “But I can tell you Jamie put the ads out there nationally. But they’re busy too, and that’s something we’ve got to consider. You’ve got all these other municipalities going through the same thing we’re going through, some worse than us.”
Aug. 7, 2020
Guillory reopens search for new police chief, The Current
“We did search nationally, but we could do a better job,” Guillory acknowledged later at a press conference.
Aug. 21, 2020
Lafayette police shoot and kill Trayford Pellerin, The Advertiser
About 150 people blocked traffic on Evangeline Thruway on Aug. 22, a main roadway into the city, chanting “Tray” to honor the victim as they locked arms.
Later that night, officers in riot gear, including shields and gas masks, confronted the marchers at a police precinct on Moss Street and ordered them to clear the road.
Dec. 23, 2020
Guillory appoints Thomas Glover as new police chief, The Current
Thomas Glover, appointed Lafayette’s first Black police chief, introduced himself as an agent of change. The longtime police veteran takes up his new post in January. Mayor-President Josh Guillory announced his selection Wednesday, filling a position left vacant for nearly a year.
Jan. 1, 2021
Glover’s term begins.
Sept. 30, 2021
Gun violence continues to surge in 2021, The Current
Lafayette police responded to 76% more gun crimes in 2020 than 2019.
So far this year, police have responded to 219 violent crime incidents involving a firearm, with aggravated assault by far the most common. If trends hold, 2021 will outpace 2020, when police responded to an average of 25.6 gun crimes a month.
Oct. 7, 2021
Mayor-President Josh Guillory fires Lafayette Police Chief Thomas Glover; no reason cited; Wayne Griffin named interim director, The Acadiana Advocate
No reason was cited for Glover’s termination, and Angelle said there would be no further comment because it is a personnel matter.
Oct. 8, 2021
Guillory administration remaining tight-lipped about former chief’s termination, KATC
“Well, it’s not really much I can say. I think it’s more appropriate just to recognize that it’s a personnel matter and we respect the process,” the mayor-president stated. “So any of those questions are more properly discussed with our HR, our legal department.”
“Chief Griffin’s very qualified. You know, he was vetted, he went through the process and, if you guys recall, a very lengthy process. Think about it, two national searches, OK, civil service test. He’s got all the requirements and credentials by law and all that good stuff. And then we, you know, we don’t want to make a rash decision.”
Oct. 19, 2021
Griffin presents to City Council; community activist Marja Broussard brings up allegation of sexual harassment.
“You know that he’s about to be brought up on some allegations of sexual harassment,” she said to Guillory.
Oct. 20, 2021
LCG calls NAACP president’s allegation a “rumor. … There has been no one who has come forward and accused the interim chief of harassing them,” spokesman Jamie Angelle says.
Oct. 21, 2021
Ousted Lafayette police chief says Guillory buried changes he was hired to make, The Current
“They were always concerned about how the mayor would look,” Glover says of Guillory’s inner circle. “So much was counter to law enforcement.”
No search scheduled for permanent Lafayette police chief after firing The Advertiser
“As of right now there’s no search scheduled, and we’re taking it day by day. I have all the confidence in the world in Chief Griffin,” Guillory stated on his weekly KPEL call-in show. “So far I’m seeing him do great things. … As of right now, look, he’s our chief of police. He’s my chief of police. [I’m] very proud of him and very proud of the police department.”
Nov. 2, 2021
Thomas Glover files appeal of termination against civil service board, KADN
According to public records requests obtained by News15, Glover says “not a single performance measure goal, or objective was ever given to the petitioner orally, in writing, or otherwise.”
Jan. 6, 2022
Griffin out as interim Lafayette Police Chief as LCG begins search for new leadership; demoted to sergeant, The Acadiana Advocate
Interim Lafayette Police Chief Wayne Griffin, on administrative leave after a sexual harassment allegation, will not return to the chief role and instead a search will be launched to find a new permanent chief, Lafayette Consolidated Government announced Thursday.
Jan. 15, 2022
Lafayette homicides rose 47% in 2021, The Acadiana Advocate
The Lafayette Parish Sheriff’s Office and Lafayette Police Department announced a joint task force focused on “disrupting” violent crime by removing stolen and illegally possessed weapons from the streets and focusing on known violent offenders, among other goals.
Jan. 23, 2022
Former interim chief terminated from Lafayette Police Department, The Current
Citing ‘the ongoing process related to the investigation and personnel involved,’ LCG attorneys refused to turn over the investigative file after The Current requested it in mid-January. Monte Potier remains in command of the department while a national search is underway. A new public records request for the letter firing Griffin is pending.
Feb. 1, 2022
The Current and Daily Advertiser file suit for Lafayette police records on sexual harassment investigation, The Current
The court action follows weeks of repeated refusals by LCG and its attorneys to turn over public records to the two media outlets.
Feb. 9, 2022
Glover’s appeal before the civil service board is scheduled to be heard. (Hearing gets postponed.)
March 9, 2022
LCG reveals influences behind Thomas Glover’s firing as his appeal challenging termination rejected, The Advocate
LCG CAO Cydra Wingerter said she highlighted some areas of concern during a September performance meeting with Glover, including the need for better communication with higher-ups, improved unity of command in LPD and increased delegation, but she and Guillory didn’t lose full confidence in Glover’s leadership until concerns were brought forward about Glover’s handling of a complaint against a Lafayette Police Department captain.
April 27, 2022
Interim Layette police chief not fired for sexual harassment, filings in public records suit reveal, The Current
He’s been pilloried in public about that,” attorney Gary McGoffin said, while also noting case law holding that a high-ranking public official like Griffin has a diminished expectation of privacy related to his employment. “There’s no victim. There’s no harassment,” he told the judge. (Judge deciding whether more information will be released.)
Nov. 1, 2022
Lafayette names first woman as new police chief. She takes position left empty for a year, The Daily Advertiser
“One of my goals is to build community relationships and do my very best to work together to solve our common concerns,” Estorge said in a release. “When police and the community work together, we build trust. We rely on our citizens to provide information about crime in their neighborhoods, and we want them to trust us. Together, we can make a difference.”
Aug. 4, 2023
Judith Estorge confirmed as Lafayette’s first female police chief, The Daily Advertiser
Lafayette Mayor-President Josh Guillory officially confirmed Judith Estorge as the chief for the Lafayette Police Department as of August 1, three months before the end of her 12-month probationary period, Lafayette Consolidated Government announced Thursday.
May 16, 2024
Losing confidence among rank and file, Lafayette Police Chief Estorge steps down, The Current
Multiple officers have expressed frustration over Estorge’s inability to work toward solutions to jail overcrowding, a longstanding problem that had officers waiting with arrestees for extended lengths of time before they could be booked.